PDA

View Full Version : Will the iPhone be undone by its keyboard?


Jose_R.A.M
06-08-2007, 04:37 AM
Engadget.com



Will the iPhone be undone by its keyboard? (http://www.engadget.com/2007/06/08/will-the-iphone-be-undone-by-its-keyboard/)

http://i136.photobucket.com/albums/q186/Jose_R-A-M/iphone-keyboard.jpg

From engadget.

For those in the audience enamored with the iPhone -- especially those willing to look past the lack of 3G and requisite 2-year service agreement -- there's really only one x-factor left: the touchscreen keyboard.

We've all seen it done, but no one's ever seen it done right -- and Steve seems to think it's going to be off the chain. So why is Dvorak, noted tech pundit, and goader of Mac users and iPhone fans, reporting that he's got insider information that the iPhone's keyboard is complete crap and "people are going to return the phone in droves"?

Well, that might have something to do with the fact that he's Dvorak, but we did consult a trusted and well connected source who, as it turns out, has heard the very same thing from multiple iPhone users, and who further noted that an accessory keyboard to go with the device may become necessary if the touchscreen keyboard doesn't cut the mustard. Of course, we can only reserve judgment until we wrap our paws on a real production model, but we hope it all turns out well -- even if only because we're sincerely frightened of an iPhone-incited fanboy riot in the streets.

What do you guys think?

That touch keyboard is the only text input on the iPhone.

Look at the size of the finger compared to the keyboard. It's ok for buttoned phones to have small keys as the slight protrusion makes sufficient contact with your digits to correctly press only that particular key. But with a flat touch screen, you're in for quite a few errors.

That would be OK with a stylus, but you're not supposed to use one. Just your finger. I think this will serve a big problem for my large hands.

The N800 impliments a nice feature where it maximises the 4.13inch screen and practically fills it with the keyboard. Nice for short web addressess, but never for anything as log as a message.

Even at the keynote, jobs was still doing typos with it. How long had he been using that before he demonstrated it to the world?

Well, that's all speculation for now. Perhaps it's a really smart touch screen, no lags and will just be a pleasure to use?

maverick786us
06-08-2007, 05:38 AM
One of my friend recently purchased motorola A 1200. Which is ultra slim, does'nt have a keypad but have a touch pad on 176*204 small screen. Unlike me she too is a software engineer.

Initially she found hard to adjust herself with the small touchpad screen, but within weeks she found it so much handy, they she hate moving back to traditional keypads.

So I have a mixed openion, users who are using computers in their regular life will find this smart touch screen intresting, for rest of the users it might be bit hard. But me being a software engineer it should'nt be undone.

Jose_R.A.M
06-08-2007, 06:10 AM
One of my friend recently purchased motorola A 1200. Which is ultra slim, does'nt have a keypad but have a touch pad on 176*204 small screen. Unlike me she too is a software engineer.

Initially she found hard to adjust herself with the small touchpad screen, but within weeks she found it so much handy, they she hate moving back to traditional keypads.

So I have a openion, users who are use computers regularly will find this smart touch screen intresting, for rest of the users it might be bit hard. But me being a software engineer it should'nt be undone.

Is she using the stylus or her fingers?

There's pluses and minuses with the touch screen. Text input with a stylus is fine but, personally, not so good with naked fingers.

Ah well, one of the iPod's winning ingredients is it's touch pad/scroll wheel/click wheel. Yes, keyboard's a totally different matter, but if the experience will be half as nice on a virtual keyboard then that'll be good enough for me.

maverick786us
06-08-2007, 06:29 AM
Is she using the stylus or her fingers?

There's pluses and minuses with the touch screen. Text input with a stylus is fine but, personally, not so good with naked fingers.

Ah well, one of the iPod's winning ingredients is it's touch pad/scroll wheel/click wheel. Yes, keyboard's a totally different matter, but if the experience will be half as nice on a virtual keyboard then that'll be good enough for me.

She is using stylus. But keypad isn't everything. There is an option of hiding the keypad. Once you hide it, you can use it like a palmtop. Yes joystick and other directional keys are there. So you can either use those keys or the stylus. Its just the alphanumeric keypad which act as touch pad

stephanie
06-08-2007, 11:26 AM
I wonder if the things they said about the iPhone touchscreen is still true? Like it will not work if you have gloves on, it will not work if you have a thin screen protector, and it will not work if you're using a stylus.

Those are really something to think about.

carcomptoy
06-08-2007, 05:59 PM
We don't realize how much muscle memory really comes into play. I'm willing to bet many people will put up with their iPhones long enough to gain some muscle memory.

brad
06-08-2007, 08:24 PM
I wonder if the things they said about the iPhone touchscreen is still true? Like it will not work if you have gloves on, it will not work if you have a thin screen protector, and it will not work if you're using a stylus.

Those are really something to think about.

Definitively won't work with a stylus, gloves, or a screen protector. The iPhone uses what is called a capacitive touch screen - the screen itself has a continuous electrical current, and it detects presses by measuring the distortion in this current caused by the current that is present in the human body. It will only work with a finger or other conductive device being held by a bare hand. It would be possible to develop some sort of a conductive stylus that must be used with a bare hand, but there are all sorts of problems associate with this.

editorshahid
06-10-2007, 10:40 PM
we don't relaize how much musical memory